November 16, 2026
|

How to Choose a GEO or AI Search Agency: 4 Tests and 10 Questions to Ask

By Daniel Davidson, founder, Long Weekend · November 2026

Disclosure: Long Weekend is a GEO and AI search agency, and I wrote this post. The tests and questions are the ones I'd use if I were hiring an agency myself. How we answer them is in a separate section at the end, so you can use the rest with anyone.

TL;DR

  • Screen any GEO or AI search agency with four tests: do they say exactly what they do, show where they are and who they serve, name specific tactics, and show dated, verifiable proof?
  • On the sales call, ask for a baseline, the exact prompts and engines they'll track, whether they report citations or just mentions, what work they'll actually do each month, and how results connect to leads.
  • Walk away from guarantees of "#1 in ChatGPT," proof with no dates, and old SEO packages with "AI" added to the name.

Choosing a GEO, AEO or AI search agency is harder than choosing an SEO agency was five years ago. The terms are new, the results are harder to see, and AI answers change from one run to the next, which makes it easy to sell a screenshot as a result. Long Weekend is an AI search and SEO agency in Cleveland's Gordon Square neighborhood, and these are the checks we'd want any buyer to run, on us or anyone else.

What four tests should an AI search agency pass?

Our own testing suggests AI engines screen agencies in a similar way. In our October 2026 test with ChatGPT (web search on, U.S.), the agency pages it cited for a Cleveland prompt had "Cleveland" plus "GEO" or "AI search" right in their titles. For national prompts, it built its answer almost entirely from third-party "best agencies 2026" roundups.

1. Do they say exactly what they do? The service name (GEO, AEO, AI SEO) should be in the page title, the headline and the first sentence, followed by a plain description of the work. If you read the homepage and still can't tell what they'd do in month one, the engagement will be just as vague.

2. Can you tell where they are and who they serve? A real location, a named founder or team, and a clear list of the kinds of businesses they work with. "We help brands grow" isn't a market.

3. Do they name specific tactics? Look for real methods: prompt tracking, citation source mapping, schema, directory and review work, digital PR, monthly re-tests. If the method is described only as "proprietary," you can't evaluate it.

4. Is their proof dated and checkable? A named client (or a clearly described one), a time frame, and a specific number. Be clear about what kind of proof it is: a traffic increase is SEO proof, not proof of AI recommendations. Both are useful, but an agency that blurs them is telling you something.

What questions should I ask a GEO agency before hiring?

1. "Will you run a baseline before we start, and can I see it?" You can't measure progress without a starting point. A baseline should list the prompts tested, the engines, the date, and who got named.

2. "Which exact prompts will you track, and can I add my own?" The prompts should be questions your customers ask, not easy wins like your brand name. Ask how many, and whether the list stays fixed so month-over-month comparisons hold up.

3. "Which engines, and how do you test them?" ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode all behave differently. Ask whether tests run with web search on, from what location, and how they deal with answers that change from run to run.

4. "Do you report citations or just mentions?" A mention means your name appeared. A citation means the engine linked a source. The useful report shows both, plus which third-party pages were cited, because those pages are usually where the work is.

5. "What will you actually do each month?" Pages built, listings fixed, reviews requested, outreach sent, articles placed. If the answer is mostly "monitoring" and "optimization," ask what that looks like in hours and deliverables.

6. "How do results tie to leads?" AI visibility is a means to an end. Ask how they track calls and form fills (GA4, call tracking) and how they'll show whether AI referral traffic is growing.

7. "What's the contract length, and what happens if I leave?" Month-to-month or a fixed term, notice period, and what's included in the fee versus billed extra.

8. "Who owns the data, pages and accounts?" Your website content, Google Business Profile, directory profiles, analytics and tracking history should belong to you. If you leave, you should keep all of it.

9. "Who will do the work?" The person on the sales call, a team member, or a subcontractor. Any of those can work. You should know which.

10. "What would make you tell me this isn't worth it?" A good agency will tell you if your market is too small, your reviews too thin, or your budget too low for the results you want. If every answer is yes, be careful.

What are the red flags when hiring an AI search agency?

  • Guaranteed "#1 in ChatGPT" or guaranteed AI recommendations. No one controls what an AI engine says. The answers vary by run, location and wording.
  • Proof with no dates, prompts or engines. One screenshot of ChatGPT naming a client proves the client was named once.
  • Old SEO with a new label. If the deliverables list is identical to a 2022 SEO retainer (blog posts, backlinks, a rankings report) and nothing mentions prompt tracking or cited sources, it's a rebrand.
  • No mention of third-party sources. AI engines rely heavily on directories, reviews and roundup articles. An agency that only talks about your website is missing most of the picture.
  • Reports you can't reproduce. You should be able to type the same prompt into the same engine and see roughly what they reported.
  • Long lock-in with no baseline. A 12-month contract signed before anyone has measured where you stand.

How does Long Weekend answer these questions?

Here's how we'd answer the 10 questions, straight.

  1. Baseline: yes. Every engagement starts by asking ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Claude and Google AI Mode 25 to 100 real customer questions and recording who gets named. You see the full results.
  2. Prompts: we track 25 customer questions every month per client, agreed with you, and keep the list stable so months compare.
  3. Engines: ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Perplexity, Claude, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode. Our tracking is built on DataForSEO, Local Falcon and Claude.
  4. Citations vs mentions: both. Step two of our process, Map, lists every page the engines cite. That list becomes the work plan.
  5. Monthly work: Build (one clear page per service and area, direct answers, FAQ, schema) and Earn (getting onto the cited directories, review sites, roundups, local press and PR). What we call The AI Visibility Loop.
  6. Leads: the same questions re-tested monthly with dated screenshots, plus calls and forms through GA4 and call tracking.
  7. Price: most engagements are $1,500 to $5,000 per month depending on services, locations and competitiveness. Legal, medical and multi-location work sits toward the top. Contract terms are set in your proposal, before you sign.
  8. Ownership: your site, profiles and data should stay yours. Ask us to spell that out in the proposal, the same as you would any agency.
  9. Who: I build our tracking myself, and your proposal names who does the rest of the work.
  10. When we'd say no: if you want guaranteed AI recommendations, results in 30 days, or won't ask customers for reviews, we're not a fit.

On proof, test four: our clearest result is SEO, not AI citations. Paulozzi LPA, an Ohio personal injury firm, saw a 381% increase in organic traffic, 4.5 million search impressions, 43,000 website visits and 5x lead volume in one year of local SEO and AI search work. We label it as what it is.

Want to see how you'd score before talking to anyone?

Run the 10 questions on us. The fastest way is our free audit: we test 15 of your customers' questions across the AI engines and send results within 1 business day. Use it as your baseline whether you hire us or someone else.

Get my free AI visibility audit

Not sure whether you need GEO, AEO or broader AI SEO? Start with GEO vs AEO vs AI SEO, or see how we approach generative engine optimization, answer engine optimization and AI SEO.

About the author

Daniel Davidson, founder. Daniel founded Long Weekend, an AI search and SEO agency in Cleveland, Ohio, in 2020 after a decade in-house and at marketing and advertising agencies, specializing in SEO and paid advertising. LinkedIn

Looking for the right digital marketing agency for your business — one that drives measurable ROI?
‍
Long Weekend helps service businesses, SaaS, ecommerce brands and more — grow with expert SEO, AI Search, Google Ads (PPC) management, paid social ads, website design, and more.

Check out all projects.

No items found.